Locals Still Driving to Rid Prospect Park of Cars

Although the Prospect Park Road Sharing Task Force's proposal slashes two car lanes to one on the park's drive, community members say the plan isn't going far enough.

Bikes, pedestrians and cars: How do all users share Prospect Park’s loop safely?

The Prospect Park Road Sharing Task Force meeting on Tuesday night for changing the lane designation for all users on the 3.3-mile long drive throughout the park.

About 150 people, cyclists, pedestrians and motorists, attended the meeting to share their point of view on the proposal, which will cut two car lanes to one 10-foot space with a three-foot shoulder, give cyclists a 10-foot wide lane divided in two for racing bikers and slower cyclists and a 14-foot, two-way lane entirely for pedestrians at all times nearest to the interior of the park.

The overwhelming majority of community members applauded the plan, but said it should go a little further—ban cars from the park completely.

Eric McClure, co-founder of Park Slope Neighbors, took the mike and shared his thoughts to the entire room:

“This plan will make the park safer for everyone, but we’re not going far enough, we need cars out of the park,” McClure said, explaining that Park Slope Neighbors conducted a radar study on the park’s West Drive last Thursday, where they found that 99 percent of cars driving along the loop were exceeding the 25 mile per hour speed limit, with an average of 39 mph.

“What we found was eye-opening,” he said, explaining that 193 cars out of 195 that they monitored with a radar gun were speeding, with a top speed of 53 mph.

“We have a golden opportunity to use science,” he said, suggesting that the Task Force run a three-month car-free park pilot this summer to see if a car-free park is, well, a safer park. “We will all benefit from a park that is a free from motor vehicles.”

Marc Russo, a 33-year Park Slope resident, said that he would rather see no cars in the park than the proposed a single lane. 

“If you have one lane in the park you are going to see massive traffic jams and if there is an accident cars will swerve into the bike lane,” Russo said, explaining that the plan “demonizes” cars and the vast majority of Brooklynites do not live a biking lifestyle. “Right now this is a dangerous plan, drivers are going to become irate and the one lane will goat them into driving dangerously. It is better to have no cars than just one lane.”

As of now, there are two lanes (a total of 23 feet) dedicated to cars during the morning and evening rush hours, 7 a.m. to 9 a.m. on the East Drive, and from 5 p.m. to 7 p.m. on the West Drive.

The Task Force found that under the proposed plan traffic may be delayed 13.3 seconds during the morning hours and 5.6 seconds during the evening.

Emily Lloyd, Prospect Park Administrator who hosted the meeting, said that the proposed plan, which the Department of Transportation is expected to roll out this spring, was created to reduce the “higher frequency of accidents that occurred last year.” 

According to the Task Force, there were nine accidents in 2011 and so far this year, there have been four accidents. Last year, left the walkers with for a while.

The plan, Lloyd said, will help prevent future accidents.

“All the signs and lane designations will be consistent and the changes are a great opportunity to increase safety for all users,” Lloyd said. “Predictability is key, if I am a cyclist I want to know that a kid won’t be running across my path, if I am a mother with a kid, I want to know that a biker won’t hit us.”

Councilman Brad Lander said if cars were banned from the park completely it could possibly start a “culture war.” But some argued that the issue is not that cars have been hitting pedestrians, but rather that cyclists have been hitting pedestrians. 

Mary Bcdel Kliner, who said she is friends with Linda Cohen, the park volunteer who suffered severe brain trauma after being hit by a cyclist on Nov. 3 while crossing West Drive near the Vanderbilt Street playground, said bikes go faster than cars in the park.

“I have never had a problem with cars, the problem is with bikers, they don’t stop at red lights, they don’t follow the rules,” Bcdel-Kleiner said. “The park should be for kids and their families. Bikes go much faster than cars.”

But at the end of the night, the issue most people had with the plan was that cars are still going to be in the park.

Michael Epstein, who wants the park to be reserved for bikers and pedestrians, said that the community should not stop advocating the ban of cars in the park.

“I think about this issue like gay marriage in the sense of the gradual process, state-by-state,” Epstein said. “Even the opponents of a car-free park know it’ll happen.”

Chicken Underwear March 03, 2012 at 08:07 PM
I am sorry Rick but there is nothing we can do to get ALL of the cyclists to stop and ALL of the rid lights in a park. So when you have some stopping and some not it is going to be very dangerous for people who think it is save to cross the road.
Jenny P. March 04, 2012 at 02:35 AM
Why are cars allowed in a park? That is ABSURD!
michael seltzer March 04, 2012 at 01:23 PM
Really- it hasn't been cars hitting pedestrians? According to a report- since 1995 there have been 102 car accidents in the park where 34 cars hit cars, 18 cars hit cyclists including one fatality and 8 cars hit pedestrians
Curious March 04, 2012 at 06:26 PM
Michael, do you have a link to that report? I'm not doubting your facts, but would love to see the full numbers. Thanks!
Sean March 22, 2012 at 06:44 AM
Rick, cars and bicycles are not equal. A car has much more mass and velocity. The idea that cars and bicycles are equal is a tool the municipality uses to prevent bicycles from actually getting the road space they need, and to protect themselves by calling cases of vehicular manslaughter "traffic accidents". The difference in weight between a man, and a man on a road bike, is about 20lbs. Usually the bikey weighs less to begin with. The key here is that if a cyclist and a pedestrian collide, they are both likely to be badly hurt. No cyclist wants to hit a pedestrian. My own observation is that the majority of these encounters must occur mid-day on the weekend, when the park is most heavily used. If a cyclist thinks he can go there at that time and train at full speed then he's not experienced, or at least he is not a good representative of the cycling community. Most of the fast guys go very early in the morning or in the evening, and in colder weather. You'll never get hit by those guys because you'll never see them. The guys out there at 2pm on saturday buzzing moms with strollers deserve to get ticketed. If I ride in the park during busy hours, I yield at crosswalks, and keep my speed down because you can't predict when a distracted pedestrian will step out, or a kid will chase a ball. But I will never sit at a red light at 5am just to make you feel secure when you're not in the park.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »